FAQs
Pie Questions? We’ve Got Answers
Can I order a whole Proud Pie?
Absolutely! Proud Pies are available as whole pies, perfect for holidays, birthdays, dinner parties, office celebrations, or simply because you’re craving pie.
Where can I pick up my pie?
You can order Proud Pie for pickup at any Dish Society location in Houston or Austin. Just choose the location that’s most convenient for you when placing yourorder.
Do you offer pie delivery?
Yes! Proud Pies are available for delivery or pickup, so you can have dessert come to you or grab it on your way to the celebration.
Can I order pie for Thanksgiving or Christmas Day?
Yes! We can have your Proud Pie ready for pickup or delivery.
For Thanksgiving, the latest day for delivery or pickup is November 25. Delivery and pickup will not be available on Thanksgiving Day.
For Christmas, the latest delivery and pickup window is the morning of December 24. Delivery and pickup will not be available on Christmas Day.
How far in advance should I order my holiday pie?
The earlier, the better! Holiday pie season gets busy, so we recommend placing your preorder as soon as you know your plans to make sure dessert is officially handled.
What Proud Pie flavors are available?
There’s something for every kind of pie person—from fruit and pecan favorites to rich chocolate and creamy classics like Key Lime and Coconut Cream. Check our current menu to see all available flavors.
Are Proud Pies gluten-free?
No. All of our current Proud Pie flavors contain gluten, either in the traditional pie crust or graham cracker crust. Our pies cannot be modified to be gluten-free.
Are your pies vegetarian?
Some of them are! Our current vegetarian Proud Pies are:
- Miss Daisy’s Fudge Pie
- State Fair Caramel Apple Pie
- Big Texas Bourbon Pecan Pie
- Big Texas Muddy Bottom Pecan Pie
- Pumpkin Pie
If you have a specific dietary restriction, please let our team know when ordering so we can help you review the current ingredients.
What allergens are in your pies?
Our current recipes contain the following allergens and dietary considerations:
Miss Daisy’s Fudge Pie
Contains gluten, egg, dairy, and soy.
Wobbly Turtle Pie
Contains gluten, egg, dairy, almonds, soy.
State Fair Caramel Apple Pie
Contains gluten and dairy.
Coconut Cream Pie
Contains gluten, egg, dairy, soy, coconut.
Michigan Cherry Pie
Contains gluten and dairy.
Key Lime Pie
Contains gluten, egg, and dairy.
Big Texas Bourbon Pecan Pie
Contains gluten, egg, dairy, and pecans.
Big Texas Muddy Bottom Pecan Pie
Contains gluten, egg, dairy, pecans, and soy.
Ghirardelli Chocolate Silk Pie
Contains gluten, egg, dairy, soy.
Pumpkin Pie
Contains gluten, egg, and dairy.
If you have a food allergy or dietary restriction, please let our team know before ordering so we can help you review the current ingredients.
How many slices are in a whole Proud Pie?
At Proud Pie, we typically cut a whole pie into 6 generous slices. Depending on your preferred portion size, a whole pie can be cut into approximately 6–10 slices, making it a great dessert for sharing with a group.
How long will my Proud Pie stay fresh?
For the best flavor and quality, we recommend enjoying your Proud Pie within 5 days. Keep your pie refrigerated until you’re ready to serve it, especially cream-based and chilled varieties.
What is the best way to serve my Proud Pie?
It depends on the flavor! Here’s how we recommend enjoying each one:
Best served cold, directly from the refrigerator:
- Ghirardelli Chocolate Silk
- Wobbly Turtle Chocolate Silk
- Coconut Cream
- Key Lime
- Traditional Pumpkin
Best brought to room temperature for about 2 hours before serving:
- Big Texas Muddy Bottom Pecan
- Big Texas Bourbon Pecan
- State Fair Caramel Apple
- Michigan State Cherry Crumble
- Ms. Daisy’s Fudge
Want it warm?
Ms. Daisy’s Fudge can also be warmed in a 350°F oven for approximately 8–10 minutes, or until warmed to your liking.
State Fair Caramel Apple and Michigan State Cherry Crumble can also be served warm if you prefer. Just keep in mind that warming these pies may make it a little harder to cut them into perfectly clean slices.
Pro tip: However you serve it, Proud Pie is best enjoyed within 5 days of purchase.
Can I order more than one pie?
Of course. Ordering for a big family gathering, office party, Friendsgiving, or holiday event? Add as many pies as you need to your order and make sure everyone gets their favorite.
Are Proud Pies available by the slice?
Yes! Many Proud Pie flavors are also available by the slice at Dish Society, making it easy to try a few before deciding which whole pie deserves a spot on your table.
Do you ship Proud Pies to other states?
In some cases, yes! Shipping availability depends on the destination state and the number of pies in your order. Reach out to us directly at proudpie@five12rc.com with your request, and our team will let you know what options may be available.
Does Proud Pie support donations or fundraisers?
Yes! We love supporting our communities whenever possible. For donation requests, fundraisers, or community partnerships, contact us directly at community@dishsociety.com with the details of your request, and our team will follow up from there.
Which pie should I choose?
That’s the hard part. Go fruity, creamy, chocolatey, nutty—or skip the decision and bring home more than one. We fully support a multi-pie table.
Ready to Check Dessert Off the List?
Order your Proud Pie for pickup or delivery and let us handle the sweetest part of the celebration.